Last month’s announcement that the U.S. government had obtained a 10% equity stake in U.S. semiconductor giant Intel raises big questions about the government’s role in the market economy.
The government historically has invested in (and sometimes briefly taken over) firms in key sectors in response to national crises—most recently, the 2008 financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic. Such investments have been justified as needed to prevent a systemic collapse that would have far-reaching and catastrophic consequences beyond the struggling companies.
Government corporate investments have also occasionally been made in support of other goals, such as promoting industrial policy and national security. The Intel investment falls into that category.
In deciding whether to pursue further equity acquisitions in tech companies, the government may wish to consider potential economic downsides associated with such acquisitions. It may be that focusing instead on further deregulatory and tax reform, which the administration is already pursuing, would be a better policy to strengthen the U.S. economy.
The Intel Investment
Most recently, in an attempt to help the struggling company avoid exiting the manufacturing sector, the Trump administration authorized investing nearly $9 billion of taxpayer money in Intel, making the U.S. government its largest shareholder. Intel characterizes the government’s investment as “passive ownership, with no Board representation or other governance or information rights.” It is still required to “vote with the Company’s Board of Directors on matters requiring shareholder approval.”
Largely funded through the CHIPS and Science Act of 2022, the investment has two primary aims:
- Reinforcing U.S. dominance in artificial intelligence, while strengthening national security.
- Bolstering U.S. semiconductor manufacturing.
The investment comes amid Intel’s declining market valuation and growing competitive pressures in the semiconductor industry. In fact, for more than a decade, the corporation has had systematic failures, driving its latest financial erosion. Shares of rivals like Nvidia and Broadcom, on the other hand, have surged past Intel.
Competitive Ramifications
The Intel investment clearly represents a move away from traditional free-market competition.
‘Hybrid Capitalism’
- Sami Karaca of Boston University’s Questrom School of Business views the Intel transaction as part of “a [broader] hybrid model of [American] capitalism, blending free-market principles with elements of state capitalism.” He holds a “wait and see attitude” regarding the ultimate economic merits of this shift, noting:
- The administration recently acquired shares in other “strategically important” firms and may create a sovereign wealth fund.
- The administration is also demanding a share of revenue from large computer-chip manufacturers, with Nvidia and AMD having to remit 15% of revenue from Chinese chip sales to get export licenses.
- Given these developments, Kacara projects “[t]he next few years will show exactly how Washington’s interventions will reshape U.S. capitalism.”
Weakened competition
Other more critical analysts view the investment as a safety net for Intel, implicitly promising that the government will not let the company fail. This special assurance for a specific competitor weakens competition. As Mercatus Center economic and fiscal policy scholar Jack Salmon explains:
Markets thrive precisely because failure is allowed. When companies mismanage, they restructure, get acquired or go bankrupt, making room for better competitors. Nationalizing Intel, even partially, short-circuits this process. It freezes a failing model in place, ensuring that taxpayers bear the cost of poor decisions while innovation withers.
There are already signs that private capital has started flowing into Intel and away from other leaders of the chip market on grounds other than competitive merit. In an apparent effort to prevent tariffs from impacting its North American operations, South Korean technology giant Samsung has already begun exploring avenues of partnership with the company.
While new deals may boost Intel’s short-term financial prospects, they may come at the expense of directing business away from more efficient American producers. In the long run, such competitive distortions could harm U.S. semiconductor innovation and undermine American competitiveness in that key sector.
Wasteful Rent Seeking
Over the past 15 years, Intel has spent more than $2 million annually on federal lobbying efforts. In last three years, the annual average has risen to $6 million.
While these rent-seeking efforts have helped the company secure a large CHIPS Act grant, Intel still suffered a significant economic slowdown, characterized by declining revenue, net losses, and a shrinking market valuation. Nor does the new government stake guarantee better financial outcomes for the company.
These efforts send a bad message to other industries, encouraging them to engage in rent-seeking activities. Government involvement in markets hinders competition and makes firms preoccupied with managing their relationships with officials, rather than devoting energy and resources to improving their products. The results are economic slowdowns and decreased innovation.
Research on Partial Government Ownership
A 2024 World Bank Study raised economic concerns about partial government ownership, as Manhattan Institute economist Daniel Di Martino explains:
[O]ne World Bank analysis last year found that companies with at least a 10 percent government stake had on average 32 percent lower labor productivity than private firms and were more than 6 percent less profitable. Partially state-owned firms across the developed world give investors rates of return nearly 5 percentage points lower than those of median private firms in their sectors.
Lessons from US History
The troubled history of U.S. government ownership or sponsorship of favored companies also raises a red flag. As Di Martino points out:
Plenty of American examples demonstrate what can go wrong when the government takes over a business. Think of the U.S. Postal Service. Completely captured by the American Postal Workers Union, it saddled taxpayers with a $9.5 billion deficit last year, following a $6.5 billion deficit the year prior.
What about privately owned companies that enjoy governmental favor?
Take Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which are privately owned, publicly traded companies chartered by Congress “to provide liquidity, stability, and affordability in the mortgage market” by buying up mortgages. Investors perceived that the government would protect Fannie and Freddie from failure due to their special status as “government-sponsored enterprises” (GSEs).
This perception insulated the GSEs from normal market forces, and U.S. taxpayers ended up the losers. In the 2008 housing-market collapse, Fannie and Freddie incurred enormous losses due to their risky lending and investing practices. To prevent a systematic crash in the U.S. financial system, the U.S. Treasury injected nearly $200 billion into Fannie and Freddie. The two firms are still operating under federal conservatorship.
This is the Fannie and Freddie lesson:
- The assumption of government backing causes corporations to take risky steps that may undermine efficiency and competitiveness.
- Losses borne by government-supported corporations become taxpayer burdens.
- Such firms gain artificial government-supplied competitive advantages, diminishing competition.
The Regulatory and Tax-Reform Alternative
For better (hopefully) or worse, the Intel investment is a done deal. In adjusting its economic policy going forward, however, the government may want to weigh the serious economic harm that could stem from future public investments in major U.S. companies. It could, if it so chooses, reject new corporate investments and rely instead on procompetitive deregulation and market-friendly tax reform as a way to strengthen the economy and U.S. competitiveness.
The administration already has taken significant steps in those areas. Presidential executive orders have committed the administration to identify and, to the fullest extent legally possible, eliminate anticompetitive market-distorting federal and state regulations. Administration trade negotiators could further energize the economy by pursuing the phaseout of anticompetitive regulatory distortions by our trading partners.
Pro-market business tax changes could strengthen the U.S. economy by boosting investment, promoting work, and improving global competitiveness. Tax reforms (such as full expensing) incorporated into the July 2025 Big Beautiful Bill are expected to grow U.S. gross domestic product by 1.2% in the long run, according to the National Taxpayers Union Foundation. The administration also might seek to advance additional pro-growth tax reforms, such as those recommended in a November 2024 report by the independent Growth Commission.
The Big Policy Picture
The administration commendably has committed itself to promote a stronger, more vibrant, faster-growing U.S. economy. In that light, regulatory and tax strategies, which are already centerpieces of the policy agenda, merit being pursued vigorously.
The case for including future public-ownership investments in the policy mix, however, appears highly dubious.
