Showing archive for: “Copyright”
Copy, Paste, Compensate: Nigeria’s Misguided Bid to Make Big Tech Pay for News
Nigeria has looked south and seen a $40 million payday for the press. The trouble is that it misread both the price tag and the fine print—and its attempt to collect may leave Nigerian publishers with fewer readers and no comparable payday. On July 6, Nigeria’s Federal Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (FCCPC) announced investigations ... Copy, Paste, Compensate: Nigeria’s Misguided Bid to Make Big Tech Pay for News
C’est Presumé: France’s AI Copyright Shortcut
Generative AI strains nearly every layer of copyright law. Policymakers have focused most on one pressure point: the use of copyrighted works to train AI models. Fitting that practice into a legal framework that supports both creative industries and the AI sector has proved difficult. Against that backdrop, a recent French Senate proposal would add ... C’est Presumé: France’s AI Copyright Shortcut
Decorative Safe Harbors: The Judicial Hollowing-Out of Intermediary Accountability
The U.S. Supreme Court just made it much harder to hold at least some internet intermediaries liable for what their users do. And in the process, it may have made key statutory safe harbors largely irrelevant. The Court’s unanimous reversal of the billion-dollar copyright verdict against Cox Communications has drawn predictable headlines. Some commentators cast ... Decorative Safe Harbors: The Judicial Hollowing-Out of Intermediary Accountability
‘Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the Cathedral,’ by Guido Calabresi & A. Douglas Melamed
Guido Calabresi and Doug Melamed’s 1972 classic “One View of the Cathedral” sets up a framework that is now standard fare for first-year law students. First-years spend their early months trying to figure out what they are doing and why they shuffle from property class to torts class. They hear terminology utterly new to them ... ‘Property Rules, Liability Rules, and Inalienability: One View of the Cathedral,’ by Guido Calabresi & A. Douglas Melamed
Complaint Claims Meta Is a Porn Pirate: Will Strike 3 Strike Out?
A company that has filed more than 6,000 copyright lawsuits against individual defendants—quickly settling most for amounts carefully calculated below the cost of defense—has now set its sights on Meta, a corporation worth more than $1 trillion. Strike 3 Holdings’ recent lawsuit against the tech giant alleging widespread piracy for training of artificial intelligence represents ... Complaint Claims Meta Is a Porn Pirate: Will Strike 3 Strike Out?
Misreading Machines: How the Copyright Office’s Report Undermines Generative AI
In a preview of its forthcoming report on copyright and artificial intelligence, the U.S. Copyright Office has unveiled a pre-publication draft of the report’s section on generative-AI training. The draft reflects a concerning tendency toward uncertainty and overreach, giving short shrift to the substantial arguments in favor of AI developers and deployers and notably discounting ... Misreading Machines: How the Copyright Office’s Report Undermines Generative AI
Systemic Risk and Copyright in the EU AI Act
The European Parliament’s approval last week of the AI Act marked a significant milestone in the regulation of artificial intelligence. While the law’s final text is less alarming than what was initially proposed, it nonetheless still includes some ambiguities that could be exploited by regulators in ways that would hinder innovation in the EU. Among ... Systemic Risk and Copyright in the EU AI Act
Blackout Rebates: Tipping the Scales at the FCC
Cable and satellite programming blackouts often generate significant headlines. While the share of the population affected by blackouts may be small—bordering on minuscule—most consumers don’t like the idea of programming blackouts and balk at the idea of paying for TV programming they can’t access. Enter the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) with a bold proposal to ... Blackout Rebates: Tipping the Scales at the FCC
Oregon Should Beware the Right to Repair
The Oregon State Legislature is considering HB 3631, a bill that would ensure that consumers have a “right to repair” their electronics devices. The legislation would require that manufacturers provide consumers and independent repair shops access to relevant repair information, as well to make available any parts or tools necessary to carry out the repair. ... Oregon Should Beware the Right to Repair
State-Mandated Digital Book Licenses Offend the Constitution and Undermine Free-Market Principles
Various states recently have enacted legislation that requires authors, publishers, and other copyright holders to license to lending libraries digital texts, including e-books and audio books. These laws violate the Constitution’s conferral on Congress of the exclusive authority to set national copyright law. Furthermore, as a policy matter, they offend free-market principles. The laws interfere ... State-Mandated Digital Book Licenses Offend the Constitution and Undermine Free-Market Principles
A Few Questions (and Even Fewer Answers) About What Artificial Intelligence Will Mean for Copyright
Not only have digital-image generators like Stable Diffusion, DALL-E, and Midjourney—which make use of deep-learning models and other artificial-intelligence (AI) systems—created some incredible (and sometimes creepy – see above) visual art, but they’ve engendered a good deal of controversy, as well. Human artists have banded together as part of a fledgling anti-AI campaign; lawsuits have ... A Few Questions (and Even Fewer Answers) About What Artificial Intelligence Will Mean for Copyright
Rules Without Reason
In his July Executive Order, President Joe Biden called on the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to consider making a series of rules under its purported authority to regulate “unfair methods of competition.”[1] Chair Lina Khan has previously voiced her support for doing so.[2] My view is that the Commission has no such rulemaking powers, and ... Rules Without Reason
