The Archives

The collection of all scholarly commentary on law, economics, and more

Showing archive for:  “Exclusionary Conduct”

Pump and Circumstance: The Politics of Italy’s Fuel-Price Caps

The Italian government is claiming a victory at the pump. Eni, the country’s largest oil company, has announced a 30-day cap on retail fuel prices. Italy’s second-largest fuel retailer, IP, controlled by the State Oil Company of Azerbaijan Republic (Socar), followed suit, as did the third-largest, Q8. Smaller rivals warn that the caps could squeeze ... Pump and Circumstance: The Politics of Italy’s Fuel-Price Caps

Gotta Catch ’Em All? Antitrust and the AI Talent Wars

The AI talent wars have produced a steady stream of stories that seem tailor-made to confirm everyone’s worst suspicions about Big Tech: nine-figure pay packages for star researchers, entire startup teams absorbed without a formal acquisition, and—most strikingly—reports of elite AI scientists paid handsomely to do nothing for a year under “garden leave” arrangements rather ... Gotta Catch ’Em All? Antitrust and the AI Talent Wars

The FTC’s Robinson-Patman Hangover

There is no special virtue in seeing a bad case through to the bitter end. At some point, persistence looks less like principle and more like a sunk cost with a docket number.  Last week, I wrote about the Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC’s) appeal in FTC v. Meta Platforms. The appeal seems to me a ... The FTC’s Robinson-Patman Hangover

In Space, No One Can See Your HHI

Two rocket companies walk into an antitrust review. They leave as a de facto monopoly. And somehow, the punchline may be that this was good for consumers, taxpayers, and maybe even competition. A little context. In 2006, Boeing and Lockheed Martin combined their launch divisions into a joint venture called United Launch Alliance (ULA). That’s ... In Space, No One Can See Your HHI

The Waterbed Effect Doesn’t Hold Water

A familiar concern in antitrust-adjacent debates goes like this: when a company such as Walmart grows large enough, it can strong-arm suppliers into steep discounts. Suppliers, in turn, recoup those lost margins by charging smaller grocery stores more. Those smaller stores raise prices. The big chain’s gains come at everyone else’s expense—prices fall on one ... The Waterbed Effect Doesn’t Hold Water

17 Million Pairings, Zero Proof

The Federal Trade Commission’s (FTC) lawsuit against Southern Glazer’s Wine & Spirits looks increasingly like a case in search of both a theory—and the facts to support it. In FTC v. Southern Glazer’s Wine & Spirits, the FTC alleges that the distributor violated the Robinson-Patman Act by offering better prices to some retailers than others, ... 17 Million Pairings, Zero Proof

The Visa Case and the Perils of Prosecuting Discounts

The U.S. Justice Department’s (DOJ) antitrust case against Visa—filed under the Biden administration—has put the debit-card market in the spotlight. Recent reporting suggests the DOJ is doubling down on a theory that Visa’s volume-based incentives and routing arrangements amount to unlawful monopolization. That claim warrants skepticism: the practices under attack are routine, efficiency-enhancing features of ... The Visa Case and the Perils of Prosecuting Discounts

The Paradox of Google Search Remedies

The U.S. Justice Department (DOJ) won its antitrust case against Google last year, establishing that the company illegally maintained its monopoly in “general search” and “general search text advertising” markets through exclusive default contracts. Now comes the hard part: crafting effective remedies.  I’m on record as saying the question of remedies would be difficult in ... The Paradox of Google Search Remedies

Some Thoughts on the Google Decision, for Those Who Haven’t ‘Binged’ It Yet

Readers of Truth on the Market are no doubt aware of Judge Amit Mehta’s Aug. 5 decision in the Google search antitrust case—that is, his 286-page memorandum and order finding Google liable for violating Section 2 of the Sherman Act (specifically, illegal monopoly maintenance in two markets: general search services and general text advertising).  Comments ... Some Thoughts on the Google Decision, for Those Who Haven’t ‘Binged’ It Yet

Judge Mehta Got It Wrong in the Google Case

U.S. District Court Judge Amit Mehta ruled in an Aug. 5 order that Google violated antitrust law by improperly maintaining a monopoly. The case focused on “general search engines” (GSEs) used for internet search, and the impropriety was the manner through which Google secured distribution in partnering with internet-browser developers, mobile-device manufacturers, and wireless carriers. ... Judge Mehta Got It Wrong in the Google Case

US v. Apple Lawsuit Has Big Implications for Competition and Innovation

The lawsuit filed yesterday by the U.S. Justice Department (DOJ) against Apple for monopolization of the U.S. smartphone market (joined by 15 states and the District of Columbia) has big implications for American competition and innovation. At the heart of the complaint is the DOJ’s assertion that: [Apple’s] anticompetitive acts include, but are not limited ... US v. Apple Lawsuit Has Big Implications for Competition and Innovation

The Conundrum of Out-of-Market Effects in Merger Enforcement

Section 7 of the Clayton Act prohibits mergers that harm competition in “in any line” of commerce. And, indeed, the Supreme Court’s decisions in Philadelphia National Bank and Topco are often cited on behalf of the proposition that this means any single cognizable market, and that anticompetitive effects in one market cannot be offset by ... The Conundrum of Out-of-Market Effects in Merger Enforcement